Drown

A place to suggest new commands, feats, skills, ...
Tyeslan
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 496
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 2:55 am
Location: Canada

Re: Drown

Post by Tyeslan » Sat May 25, 2013 9:18 pm

The helpfile was updated within the last year. So I tend to go by what the PK helpfile states. It used to be that insta-kills were a no, but not any longer. All spells, regardless are usable except for the instance of time-stop.
User avatar
Tamryn
Sword Master
Sword Master
Posts: 238
Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 1:37 am
Location: Zhentil Keep

Re: Drown

Post by Tamryn » Sat May 25, 2013 9:23 pm

Well, it doesn't say that they can't be used. Only that they can't be used to stun: because you can't, ICly, stun someone with an instant-kill spell.

(I actually assume this applies to PK and PvE equally...)
Tyeslan
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 496
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 2:55 am
Location: Canada

Re: Drown

Post by Tyeslan » Sat May 25, 2013 9:30 pm

Tamryn wrote:Well, it doesn't say that they can't be used. Only that they can't be used to stun: because you can't, ICly, stun someone with an instant-kill spell.

(I actually assume this applies to PK and PvE equally...)
Correct. They will not stun, they will just kill. I don't believe this is an issue, and should be left to be discussed between those having the PK. Helpfile states it can be used. If there is an issue with instant kill spells, and a PK someone runs into, it needs to be taken to the appropriate channels, or complaint forum :)

I like the idea of instant kills spells having either death, or instant kill placed near the title. For instance:

Weird
====
Illusion (Phantasm) [Death/Kill] [Fear, Mind-affecting]
blahblah

Just for clarification because sometimes descriptions don't seem as they mean. As in the case of drown.
User avatar
Tamryn
Sword Master
Sword Master
Posts: 238
Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 1:37 am
Location: Zhentil Keep

Re: Drown

Post by Tamryn » Sat May 25, 2013 9:33 pm

Tyeslan wrote:Correct. They will not stun, they will just kill.
No, they will stun, at least in my testing.
I like the idea of instant kills spells having either death, or instant kill placed near the title.
I'm not especially bothered about this, but SRD does say 'dies instantly' in the description where appropriate, which seems sufficient. This is the new text I wrote for DROWN:
You create water in the lungs of the affected target. If the target is
affected by water breathing, or otherwise has no need to breathe air, it is
unaffected. Otherwise, if it is unable to cough up the water from its lungs,
it dies instantly.
Tyeslan
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 496
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 2:55 am
Location: Canada

Re: Drown

Post by Tyeslan » Sat May 25, 2013 9:37 pm

When you go swimming, it causes you to take damage while you drown :D That is what I am in reference to, and I was unaware that you could possibly be the only one interested in this. SRD might say one thing, but not everyone uses that site to look, and it could be nice to have notification of it otherwise.
User avatar
Tamryn
Sword Master
Sword Master
Posts: 238
Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 1:37 am
Location: Zhentil Keep

Re: Drown

Post by Tamryn » Sat May 25, 2013 9:44 pm

Tyeslan wrote:When you go swimming, it causes you to take damage while you drown :D That is what I am in reference to
That's not how drown (the spell) works though. It just kills you. (Or stuns you, in spar or stun killmodes.) I'm not saying that instant-kill spells shouldn't be used, I agree that the policy says they're allowed. The only problem is whether they can be used to stun people, instead of killing them: the forum PK policy says they can't.
SRD might say one thing, but not everyone uses that site to look, and it could be nice to have notification of it otherwise.
I don't mean that everyone should go and read the SRD. Rather, that when describing these spells, SRD uses the phrase 'dies instantly' (or similar) in the description to indicate it, which seems sufficient to convey the idea. So, we could do the same thing with our help files.
Tyeslan
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 496
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 2:55 am
Location: Canada

Re: Drown

Post by Tyeslan » Sat May 25, 2013 9:50 pm

You seem to be missing my point of: When drowning on the game, you take damage, therefore someone could associate that the spell would just damage not kill, therefore, I say to put something very simple as death or kill in the upper part of the spell file to determine if it is an insta death spell or not. All it would take is a quick look, and then you can go on your way without having to read the whole helpfile. Thank you!
User avatar
Tamryn
Sword Master
Sword Master
Posts: 238
Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 1:37 am
Location: Zhentil Keep

Re: Drown

Post by Tamryn » Sat May 25, 2013 9:58 pm

Ah, then I agree! Sorry!
User avatar
Alitar
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 1103
Joined: Thu Mar 08, 2012 5:40 am
Location: Canada

Re: Drown

Post by Alitar » Sun May 26, 2013 4:24 am

As Anguin showed us, there is a ruling already on where Instant Kill spells fit. They're fit for killing opponents, not for stunning them. This rule is posted on the forums and I think it oughta be posted in the helpfile for PvP/PK as well. Though I'm curious as to why they'd fit into spar... I'm fairly certain spar is non-lethal. (isn't it? Pretty sure Harroghty's knocked Alitar unconcious in spar a few times...)
Can instant-death spells be used in PKills?
* Yes, but roleplay must happen before the fight as in all other instances.
* Instant-death spells should not be used in killmodes other than spar or kill; it isn't instant-stun.
- Mele, under the heading "Policy: PK"

tl;dr I think the quoted policy above should be shown in the PK/PvP helpfile. Also, a helpfile containing a list of which spells are Instant Kill(and a note in those spell's helpfiles) would be helpful.
"The noir hero is a knight in blood caked armour. He's dirty and he does his best to deny the fact that he's a hero the whole time."
~Frank Miller
User avatar
Raona
Staff
Staff
Posts: 4944
Joined: Fri Aug 19, 2005 3:40 pm
Location: Waterdeep - Halls of Justice
Contact:

Re: Drown

Post by Raona » Sun May 26, 2013 11:36 am

I feel like this is all getting a little ticky-tacky. How about this for a policy:
"It is not permissible to intentionally initiate any action that you can reasonably expect would instantly kill an opponent while in killmode stun. This includes instant-death spells (like drown, power word kill, etc.) and other actions which would reasonably lead to the instant death of your opponent."

But honestly, having written that...I'm kind of lost on the point. Why is instant-stun off the table, if instant-death is not? Doesn't your level 50 orc hitting my level 12 gnome with their greatsword amount to the same thing? Is the idea that it is not IC to use a death spell to simply incapacitate someone, and that to stun them you have to beat them (carefully) to within an inch of their life?
Nylo
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 447
Joined: Tue Jul 26, 2011 7:15 pm
Location: Ohio, USA

Re: Drown

Post by Nylo » Sun May 26, 2013 12:04 pm

ICly, the orc could just hit the gnome gently in the side of the head with the flat of his blade to have the desired affect. But there's no IC way to turn an instadeath into an instastun.
Nylo, Fighter of Tempus
Anver, Transmuter of Garl
Malic, Cleric of Tyr
Luthir, Druid of Mielikki
User avatar
Gwain
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 2354
Joined: Tue Nov 01, 2005 9:25 pm
Location: Waterdeep

Re: Drown

Post by Gwain » Sun May 26, 2013 2:26 pm

Raona wrote:
But honestly, having written that...I'm kind of lost on the point. Why is instant-stun off the table, if instant-death is not? Doesn't your level 50 orc hitting my level 12 gnome with their greatsword amount to the same thing? Is the idea that it is not IC to use a death spell to simply incapacitate someone, and that to stun them you have to beat them (carefully) to within an inch of their life?
I agree with this, why can't insta-death spells be used to stun? I watched someone use drown on another and it was in my opinion counteractive to rp as it simply ended after the spell. I would have no issue with someone holding back at the last second and making their opponent lose conciousness instead of being killed.
Justice is not neccesarily honourable, it is a tolerable business, in essence you tolerate honour until it impedes justice, then you do what is right.

Spelling is not necessarily correct :)
User avatar
Alitar
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 1103
Joined: Thu Mar 08, 2012 5:40 am
Location: Canada

Re: Drown

Post by Alitar » Sun May 26, 2013 3:50 pm

Drown is a bit different than other death spells because, in my opinion, it shouldn't be an instant death. I think it should be a Four-Rounds-of-Dying during which you should have a command to stop the spell. Umberlants waterboarding their captives would an interesting RP.

That aside, I see spells as being like science. Put the spell into motion and it cannot be stopped. Like mixing two chemicals. That's how it's usually portrayed in the books(protagonist throws a spell and watches helplessly in slow motion as the wrong person steps into the way). Can't stop the fireball in the air once it's going. Drown puts water into lungs, it doesn't take it out. Wail of the Banshee throws a death-scream , it can't mute it once it is echoing in the victim's soul etc. etc. etc.

By my understanding, spells can't be taken back. We can suspend belief by allowing things like fireball to do non-lethal because it is a damaging spell and without doing that casters really couldn't spar non-casters; also, it isn't too hard to imagine a caster changing a couple words to make the fireball more "HE" than "incendiary". An instant kill spell, however... well... it's ICly intended to be instantly lethal. :S It could be looked at on a spell-by-spell basis but personally, I agree with the instant kill spells instantly killing things, not instantly stunning them.

Also, if I've come across as ticky-tacky I'm sorry! Definitely isn't my intent!
"The noir hero is a knight in blood caked armour. He's dirty and he does his best to deny the fact that he's a hero the whole time."
~Frank Miller
User avatar
Casamir
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 286
Joined: Tue Aug 04, 2009 2:27 am
Location: The Twilit Grottoes beneath Exham Priory
Contact:

Re: Drown

Post by Casamir » Mon May 27, 2013 12:55 am

While I am all for (waterboarding) humbly embracing the Queen's Mercy, I think that it fits more in the realm of RP. If the SRD has it as a kill spell, it should be a kill spell. Mostly it seems that everything is fine the way it is, other than expanding the help files to indicate what is a kill spell. Now the stun vs death, I think could be considered the difference between dropping someone to 0 hp vs -10 hp in PNP. Dying and almost dead, versus actually six feet under. The orc may leave that upstart gnome clinically dead for a small spat. I feel it's better left to IC discretion than OOC mandating, short of actual abuse. You try and murder someone with a spell during a friendly spar, and you will have to deal with the IC consequences.
"Get thee back into the tempest and the Night's Plutonian shore!" "'Tis as impossible that he's undrowned as he that sleeps here swims." "I'm begging you please wake me up, In all my dreams I...."
User avatar
Tamryn
Sword Master
Sword Master
Posts: 238
Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 1:37 am
Location: Zhentil Keep

Re: Drown

Post by Tamryn » Mon May 27, 2013 1:02 am

Casamir wrote:If the SRD has it as a kill spell, it should be a kill spell.
You know... perhaps the best solution to this is to have these spells always be kill spells. So if you cast one in killmode stun... it still kills your target. Which fits with 'stun' being pulling a blow with a sword, but the impossibility of 'pulling' something like drown or phantasmal killer.

Having a note saying so in the help file seems like fair warning for that behaviour.
User avatar
Kaaurk
Sword Master
Sword Master
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Jul 26, 2010 6:43 am

Re: Drown

Post by Kaaurk » Mon May 27, 2013 2:17 am

In my opinion any spell that can kill should. I mean you're not going to to be able to cast a fire ball and make it not be fatal if the person can't take the damage it gives. You cannot pull back a spell like you could a blow from a sword or the like. So really Instant death spells are really like every other spell it just takes one of them instead of a few.
User avatar
Alitar
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 1103
Joined: Thu Mar 08, 2012 5:40 am
Location: Canada

Re: Drown

Post by Alitar » Mon May 27, 2013 6:05 am

Drown in canon(or at least, I think that's what I found) has the subject hit 0HP instantly and the next round they drop to -1. The third round they're dead unless someone succeeds a DC15 Heal check.
http://dndtools.eu/spells/underdark--34/drown--3485/
Anyone know of a better source than this? I've never seen this website before...
"The noir hero is a knight in blood caked armour. He's dirty and he does his best to deny the fact that he's a hero the whole time."
~Frank Miller
User avatar
Hrosskell
Staff
Staff
Posts: 599
Joined: Wed Jun 30, 2004 9:14 pm
Location: Silverymoon

Re: Drown

Post by Hrosskell » Tue May 28, 2013 2:30 am

That's actually a pretty reliable source, long used for feat look up and source-book referencing. They list down at the bottom what books it can be found in (not the page number for this one). I owe almost my entire knowledge of 3.0/3.5 fighter cheese-play (some would say optimization or at least making them on par with wizards) to this site and Giant in the Playgrounds.
Jamais arriere.
User avatar
Rhangalas
Sword Grand Master
Sword Grand Master
Posts: 374
Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2011 12:51 pm
Location: The Port of Shadows

Re: Drown

Post by Rhangalas » Fri Jun 14, 2013 6:40 am

Gwain wrote:Enervation is not a instant death spell, it is a spell that causes the target to suffer negative levels.
Ah, I've never used the spell with any of my PCs. I didn't know FK handled it differently, but Enervation is supposed to be instant death if the criteria are met:

http://www.d20srd.org/srd/spells/enervation.htm
"I have a lot of beliefs... and I live by none of them."
- Louis C.K.
User avatar
Raona
Staff
Staff
Posts: 4944
Joined: Fri Aug 19, 2005 3:40 pm
Location: Waterdeep - Halls of Justice
Contact:

Re: Drown

Post by Raona » Sat Jun 15, 2013 11:30 am

I appreciate the comments and feedback. I think the staff needs to have a huddle on this and confirm our current policy or revise it, then make it as clear as possible in the helpfiles. I almost never PvP kill/spar but I know folks do and the rules have to be crystal clear to reduce the possibility of hard feelings to a minimum.
Post Reply