Teaching and scholar feat
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 8:55 am
01Alright, I open here an old debate about teaching :p
I see teaching as the spell teaching.
I know skills area differents, but there area many more spells than skills in game and I guess they are more affected by the teaching.
For now, you need the scholar feat (even twice) to be able to teach high level spells
BUT
if you know whatever spell as inept, you can scribe it as a scroll, give the scroll away and the other learn the spell writing the scroll in his spellbook, learning it as inept.
So most teaching rp ends as... you do all the rp, then scribe the scroll and give it....
And I guess that in most case, the share of magical knowledge in fk is some scroll sold or given away with no rp around, which is IC but is sad to me
What point is there in the scholar feat to prevent to use the right teaching commands to do the same things ?
I completely agree on the teacher feat, allowing you to teach better (as it requires some abilities to be a good teacher).
But as spells are as simple to learn (for the basics) as cooking recipes (you copy the recipe in your book, follow it, and you know the basics), it should be possible for anyone knowing a spell to teach it as inept and (for me) the scholar feat could be removed from the game.
It would only help in inciting for more rp in game rather than scrolls given away, I don't really see downsides in that.
El
I see teaching as the spell teaching.
I know skills area differents, but there area many more spells than skills in game and I guess they are more affected by the teaching.
For now, you need the scholar feat (even twice) to be able to teach high level spells
BUT
if you know whatever spell as inept, you can scribe it as a scroll, give the scroll away and the other learn the spell writing the scroll in his spellbook, learning it as inept.
So most teaching rp ends as... you do all the rp, then scribe the scroll and give it....
And I guess that in most case, the share of magical knowledge in fk is some scroll sold or given away with no rp around, which is IC but is sad to me
What point is there in the scholar feat to prevent to use the right teaching commands to do the same things ?
I completely agree on the teacher feat, allowing you to teach better (as it requires some abilities to be a good teacher).
But as spells are as simple to learn (for the basics) as cooking recipes (you copy the recipe in your book, follow it, and you know the basics), it should be possible for anyone knowing a spell to teach it as inept and (for me) the scholar feat could be removed from the game.
It would only help in inciting for more rp in game rather than scrolls given away, I don't really see downsides in that.
El